sdayman... Thanks for responding. You are right about Cloudflare and I checked the IP address as you did and found it to be Clouflare.
Wordfence was comparing my Old DNS records (A record) which is the same IP address for all my sites on Cloudflare to the New DNS records (A record) which is a different Cloudflare IP address that had me puzzled at first, and thinking my site was hacked. Gosh... Glad that's over with.
I clicked the 'Resolve: I know about this change' link as well.